Color for the lid: eyeshadows
Powders, from matte to glitter
With powder eyeshadows, you choose by finish, which ranges from matte to satin to glitter and sequin. Lancôme's Idôle Goddess Dimension Ombretto Mono is a highly pigmented single shadow in a matte, satin or glitter finish, with micro-aerated powder technology. Sisley's Phyto-Ombres are single shadows in five finishes: matte, satin, metallic, glow and sequin, with a texture that leaves an ultra-thin smoothing film. The Magnificent Eye Shadow Trousse Natural by Mazzolari has a silicone-based formula with spherical powders and a high percentage of pearls for iridescence.
Liquid, metallic and stick shadows
Alongside powders there are liquid, metallic and stick shadows, each with its own texture. Giorgio Armani's Luminous Silk Eye Tint is a liquid eyeshadow with a water-based formula. Bobbi Brown's Luxe Eye Shadow is a poured metallic shadow in Rich Lustre, Rich Metal and Rich Sparkle finishes, which the brand suggests applying dry for a bold effect or with a damp brush for a more metallic look. From the same brand, the Long-Wear Cream Shadow Stick is a multi-use formula that glides over the lid to add depth, define or highlight.
One product for several steps
If you want a single product, there are formulas that work as eyeshadow and also as pencil, liner or base. Sisley's Phyto-Eye Twist combines eyeshadow, pencil and liner in a melting jumbo lead, with plant actives from green tea, white lily and camellia. Danessa Myricks Beauty's Colorfix Stix Duo is a stick with pearlescent pigments to use as eyeshadow, alone or as a base, and also on cheeks and lips.
Defining the eyes: pencils and eyeliners
A line you can smudge
A pencil draws a line you can blend. Tom Ford's Gel Eyeliner is a creamy, blendable gel pencil in Cream, Cocoa and Black, and Estée Lauder's Double Wear Infinite Waterproof Eyeliner has a soft smudging tip and a built-in sharpener.
A sharp or graphic line
For a sharp line there is liquid eyeliner. Tom Ford's Eye Defining Pen is a dual-ended liquid eyeliner, with a calligraphy tip on one side and a brush tip on the other, for elegant or elongated lines. Shiseido's ArchLiner Ink has an arched micro tip, a steady-flow system and an ultra-black pigment that dries quickly. Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner combines the effect of a liquid with the application of a gel and lets you perfect the line before it sets.
For a graphic look or a shimmering line there are other eyeliners. Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Waterproof Liner has a brush tip and a chrome finish for graphic looks, and the Magic Eyeliner Pen by Mazzolari gives a shimmering line with an alcohol-free, silicone-free texture.
Mascara for volume, curl and length
Volume
For volume there are mascaras that focus on exactly that effect. They include Lancôme's Mascara Hypnôse Drama, Yves Saint Laurent's Lash Clash with iris extract and Sensai's Lash Volumiser 38°C, with a Lash Volumising Film formula and a triple-spiral brush that fans the lashes out.
Other mascaras use fibers to build volume. Estée Lauder's Sumptuous Extreme has three kinds, and Clinique's High Impact High-Fi uses dimensional fibers.
Volume can also come with intense black or with color. The Volume Up Mascara by Mazzolari has a rich texture with pure pigment for an intense black, and Shiseido's ControlledChaos MascaraInk gives graphic, buildable volume in black, sapphire, violet and emerald.
Curl and length
To curl lashes there are mascaras with dedicated formulas and brushes. Lancôme's Lash Idôle Curl Goddess works on curl with a fast-acting curl complex and a brush with fibers twisted at 40°. Sisley's So Curl curls and coats the lashes, with a treatment formula based on a vitaminized peptide and arginine.
There are also mascaras made for length, each with its own brush. Lancôme's Flutter Extension separates and defines, Giorgio Armani's Vertigo Lift has the Infinity-loop brush and Shiseido's ImperialLash MascaraInk has soft silicone-based bristles and a dual application.
Brows: shape and hold
A pencil defines the shape of the brows, powder fills them in and gel sets the hairs. Among the pencils, Tom Ford's Brown Pencil has a spoolie that spreads a powdery texture for a natural finish, and Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Brow Pencil has a slanted tip and a built-in spoolie.
If you want pencil and powder in a single tool, choose a 3-in-1. Shiseido's Brow InkTrio and Estée Lauder's Brow Multitasker combine pencil, powder with a sponge applicator, and a brush.
To set the hairs there are gels and creams. Sisley's Phyto-Sourcils Fix contains nylon fibers, Tom Ford's Eye Brow Laminator is a clear cream and Bobbi Brown's Natural Brow Shaper is a tinted gel with a natural look.
Before color: eye and lash primers
Primer prepares the base before color, on the lid or on the lashes. Tom Ford's Emotionproof Eye Primer is an eyeshadow base, a sheer pink cream that dries to a veil and, according to the brand, makes eyeshadow more luminous. Estée Lauder's Little Black Primer can be worn alone for a silky black, under mascara as a primer or over it as a finish.
You'll also find dedicated products in eyeshadows, mascara, eyeliner and eye primers, and to take it all off there is the makeup removers collection.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between powder, liquid and stick eyeshadow?
The texture and formula change. Lancôme's Idôle Goddess Dimension is a micro-aerated powder in a matte, satin or glitter finish, while Giorgio Armani's Luminous Silk Eye Tint is a liquid with a water-based formula. Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Cream Shadow Stick is a multi-use stick for adding depth, defining or highlighting.
Pencil or liquid eyeliner: which is better for eye makeup?
A pencil draws a line you can blend, while liquid eyeliner traces a sharp line. Tom Ford's Gel Eyeliner is a creamy, blendable gel pencil, and from the same brand the Eye Defining Pen is a dual-ended liquid eyeliner with a calligraphy tip and a brush tip. Shiseido's ArchLiner Ink has an arched micro tip.
Which mascara is best for curling straight lashes?
Lancôme's Lash Idôle Curl Goddess is designed for curl, with a fast-acting curl complex and a brush with fibers twisted at 40°. Sisley's So Curl also curls and coats the lashes, with a treatment formula based on a vitaminized peptide, arginine and provitamin B5.
Which mascara is best for lengthening lashes?
For length there is Lancôme's Lash Idôle Flutter Extension, with a brush that separates and defines every lash, and Giorgio Armani's Vertigo Lift with the Infinity-loop brush. Shiseido offers the ImperialLash MascaraInk, with soft silicone-based bristles and a dual application system.
Which mascara gives lashes the most volume?
Volumizing mascaras include Lancôme's Hypnôse Drama, Yves Saint Laurent's Lash Clash with iris extract, Giorgio Armani's Vertigo Drama with kaolin clay and Sensai's Lash Volumiser 38°C. Estée Lauder's Sumptuous Extreme and Clinique's High Impact High-Fi, on the other hand, use fibers.
Which mascara is best if you wear contact lenses?
Clinique recommends the High Impact Waterproof Mascara for contact lens wearers too: it is ophthalmologist-tested, allergy-tested and fragrance-free. The same features, meaning ophthalmologist testing, allergy testing and no fragrance, are stated for the Chubby Lash Fattening Mascara, also by Clinique.
Is there one product that works as eyeshadow, pencil and eyeliner?
Yes, Sisley's Phyto-Eye Twist, a melting jumbo lead that colors the lid, draws graphic shapes or traces a thick liner, with plant actives from green tea, white lily and camellia. There is also Danessa Myricks Beauty's Colorfix Stix Duo, a pearlescent stick for eyes, cheeks and lips.
Pencil, powder or gel for brows?
A pencil defines the shape, powder fills in and gel sets the hairs. Shiseido's Brow InkTrio and Estée Lauder's Brow Multitasker combine pencil and powder in a single tool, while the gels include Sisley's Phyto-Sourcils Fix, with nylon fibers, and Bobbi Brown's tinted Natural Brow Shaper.
What does an eye or lash primer do?
Primer prepares the base before color. Tom Ford's Emotionproof Eye Primer is a sheer pink cream that dries to a veil under eyeshadow, while Estée Lauder's Little Black Primer is designed for lashes and can be worn alone for a silky black, under mascara as a primer or over it as a finish.