Eye pencils for a precise line or full color
For a clean line along the lashes you need pencils designed for precision. Sisley's Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof is a twist-up pencil with a retractable lead and built-in sharpener, with a creamy, compact tip for smooth, very precise application. Giorgio Armani's Smooth Silk Eye Pencil is also designed for precise definition.
If you're after color, you can choose a gel lead. Estée Lauder's Double Wear Waterproof Gel Eye Pencil has a highly pigmented, light and creamy formula that glides on easily and leaves full, even color.
To color the whole lid
For the whole lid you need a wide lead or a stick. Sisley's Phyto-Eye Twist combines eyeshadow, pencil and liner, with a melting, smooth jumbo lead that colors the lids, draws graphic shapes or traces an XXL liner. Bobbi Brown has the Long-Wear Cream Shadow Stick, a multi-use cream stick that glides on effortlessly and that the house offers to add depth, define and brighten the eyes.
For a waterproof or treatment formula
If you want a waterproof pencil, there are three labeled as such: Sisley's Phyto-Khol Star and Phyto-Eye Twist and Estée Lauder's Double Wear Gel Eye Pencil. Phyto-Eye Twist also has a treatment formula with plant-based actives, namely green tea, white lily and camellia, which according to Sisley care for the delicate skin of the eyelids.
For colors other than black
Alongside the dark shades there are colorful and luminous pencils. The Smooth Silk Eye Pencil also comes in blue, gray and mauve. Phyto-Khol Star shades fall into two effects: Sparkling, luminous with delicate glitter, and Mystic, deep with soft reflections. The Bobbi Brown stick ranges from the most delicate shades to the boldest.
To fill in and shape the brows
For the brows you need a pencil that fills in and shapes the hairs. Tom Ford's Brown Pencil has one end to apply color and fill in, and a professional spoolie that distributes the powder texture over the hairs with a natural finish. Estée Lauder's Brow Multitasker 3-in-1 combines a pencil with a triangular tip, a sponge applicator with powder and a small brush to shape and comb. More products are in the brows collection.
For kohl and for a liquid line there are the kajal and eyeliner collections, and eye makeup is completed with eyeshadows and mascaras.
Frequently asked questions
How do you apply eye pencil?
It depends on the pencil and the result you want. A precise tip draws the line, while a jumbo lead colors the lid. Sisley's Phyto-Khol Star has a creamy, compact tip designed for precise application, and Phyto-Eye Twist, from the same house, colors the lids, draws graphic shapes or traces an XXL liner.
Is a twist-up pencil better than one you sharpen?
With Sisley's Phyto-Khol Star Waterproof you don't have to choose: it's a twist-up pencil with a retractable lead and it also has a built-in sharpener. According to the house, the lead glides with unprecedented smoothness and the shades, with multiple effects, are designed to intensify the eyes.
Can you use an eyeliner pencil as eyeshadow?
Yes, if the lead is jumbo or creamy. Sisley's Phyto-Eye Twist is eyeshadow, pencil and liner in one, with a melting, smooth lead. Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Cream Shadow Stick is also a multi-use cream stick designed to add depth, define and brighten the eyes.
What is a gel eyeliner pencil?
It's a pencil with a gel lead, creamy and pigmented. In Estée Lauder's Double Wear Waterproof Gel Eye Pencil, the formula is highly pigmented, light and creamy, glides on easily and leaves full, even color. The pencil also has two ends.
What colors of eyeliner pencil are there besides black?
There are colorful and luminous pencils. Giorgio Armani's Smooth Silk Eye Pencil also comes in blue, gray and mauve. Sisley's Phyto-Khol Star has Sparkling shades, luminous with delicate glitter, and Mystic shades, deep with soft reflections. The Bobbi Brown stick ranges from delicate to bold tones.
What is the difference between an eyeliner pencil and a brow pencil?
A brow pencil fills in and shapes the hairs; it isn't for drawing a line around the eyes. Tom Ford's Brown Pencil, for example, has one end to apply color and a professional spoolie that distributes the powder texture over the brows with a natural finish.
How does the Estée Lauder Brow Multitasker 3-in-1 work?
The Brow Multitasker combines three tools in a single product. At one end is the pencil with a triangular tip, which fills in and defines; in the middle is a sponge applicator that releases powder for volume; and finally there is a small brush that shapes and combs the brows. The applicator allows a light or more intense effect.
Can an eyeliner pencil contain skincare actives?
Yes, for example Sisley's Phyto-Eye Twist has a treatment formula with plant-based actives, namely green tea, white lily and camellia, which according to the house care for the delicate skin of the eyelids. The actives are in a jumbo pencil that Sisley states is waterproof.