For a thin, precise line
For a very fine line, the tip and the brush are what matter. Shiseido's Microliner Ink has an ultra-fine tip you can dot between the lashes or apply along the lash line, and a heat-sensitive formula that turns from solid to liquid on contact with the skin, with a saturated matte color. From the same house, the Archliner Ink has an arched micro-tip, an ergonomic design and a steady flow of color, with an ultra-black pigment that dries quickly, and Shiseido designed it to help overcome application insecurities. If you prefer a brush, try Sisley's Pinceau Traceur, straight and flat with soft, wavy synthetic bristles, made to trace an eyeliner line or intensify eye makeup.
For an extended wing or a graphic look
To extend the line or draw a graphic stroke, the brands offer liquids with a calligraphy tip or a brush tip. Tom Ford's Eye Defining Pen is double-ended, with a calligraphy tip and a fine brush, for elegant or elongated lines and a doe-eyed effect, and the house formulated it for the deepest black. Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Waterproof Liner, with a brush tip, has a chrome finish designed for runway-inspired graphic looks and dries down to a budge-proof, flexible finish.
Sensai's Designing Liquid Eyeliner, in Black and Deep Brown, has a fine brush tip, and the house offers it for lines ranging from a classic bold line to a slim wing. You refill it by inserting the 0.6 ml refill into the holder.
For intense color
For intense color, there are richly pigmented formulas. The Magic Eyeliner Pen from the Mazzolari line is a pen eyeliner that pairs three polymers with its applicator for a glossy, even stroke, and thanks to its high pigment load the color is intense. The formula contains humectant molecules and is free of alcohol, silicones and parabens. Tom Ford offers the Gel Eyeliner, a creamy, ultra-pigmented gel pencil the house describes as blendable, in Cream, Cocoa and Black.
Waterproof and water-resistant eyeliner
Among pencils and gels, some formulas are described by the brand as waterproof or water-resistant. Estée Lauder presents the Double Wear Infinite Waterproof Eyeliner, a retractable pencil with a built-in sharpener, as waterproof: it doesn't run or smudge and holds up to sweat, heat and humidity.
Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner, in Black Ink, Espresso Ink and Caviar Ink, is described as water-resistant and combines the effect of a liquid with the application of a gel. You pick it up with the brand's Ultra Fine Eye Liner Brush, a super-thin brush with dense, tapered bristles that is easy to hold and handle. Bobbi Brown recommends wiping the excess off the brush first and working quickly, because the product sets as it dries. Draw the line as close to the lash line as possible and, if you want it thicker, simply go over it a second time.
You'll find the other pencils in the eye pencils collection and kohl liners in the kajal collection. To complete the eye look there are mascara, eyeshadows and makeup brushes.
Frequently asked questions
How do you apply gel eyeliner?
Gel eyeliner is picked up with a thin brush and applied along the lashes. For the Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner, Bobbi Brown recommends the tip of the Ultra Fine Eye Liner Brush. The color glides on smoothly and lets you perfect the line before it fully dries, without creasing.
What's the best liquid eyeliner for beginners?
If liquid eyeliner makes you nervous, try Shiseido's Archliner Ink, which the house designed precisely to help overcome application insecurities. The arched micro-tip, the ergonomic design and the steady-flow system, which always delivers the same amount of color, all help. The pigment is ultra-black and dries quickly.
What's the difference between liquid, gel and pencil eyeliner?
The applicator and the texture change. Liquid goes on with a fine brush or a tip, as with Sensai's Designing Liquid Eyeliner, while Bobbi Brown's gel is picked up with a brush and perfected before it dries. Pencils, like Estée Lauder's Double Wear Infinite, are sharpened and can be smudged.
Which eyeliner is best for a winged or graphic line?
For an extended wing, Tom Ford offers the Eye Defining Pen, whose calligraphy tip and fine brush allow elegant or elongated lines and a doe-eyed effect. For runway-inspired graphic looks there's Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Waterproof Liner instead, with a brush tip and a chrome finish.
Black or colored eyeliner: what shades are available?
Besides black there are browns, blues and bold colors. Shiseido's Microliner Ink comes in shades inspired by Japanese calligraphy, from Navy and Plum to Teal and Burgundy. Tom Ford's Gel Eyeliner is available in Cream, Cocoa and Black, and Estée Lauder's Double Wear Infinite in Kohl Noir, Espresso and Indigo.
Which eyeliner can you smudge?
Creamy pencils and soft-tip pencils can be smudged. Tom Ford describes its Gel Eyeliner, a gel pencil, as blendable, while Estée Lauder's Double Wear Infinite has a soft tip and should be smudged before the color sets. Sisley's Pinceau Traceur also works to set or smudge a pencil line.
How do you apply eyeliner between your lashes?
You need a very fine tip, like the ultra-fine tip of Shiseido's Microliner Ink, which you can dot between the lashes or apply along the lash line. Alternatively, use Sisley's Pinceau Traceur to line the base of the lashes with an eyeshadow, or Bobbi Brown's Ultra Fine Eye Liner Brush with a dark eyeshadow.
Is there a refillable eyeliner?
Yes, Sensai's Designing Liquid Eyeliner has a refill system, with a refill you insert into the holder. It's a liquid with a fine brush tip, in Black and Deep Brown, which the house offers for lines ranging from a classic bold line to a slim wing, with a precise, defined stroke.
Which eyeliner is free of alcohol and silicones?
The Magic Eyeliner Pen from the Mazzolari line has a texture free of alcohol, silicones and parabens. It's a pen eyeliner that pairs three polymers with its applicator for a glossy, even stroke, and its formula, gentle on the skin, contains humectant molecules and a high pigment load for intense color.